Devint

Performance evaluation

Hire Developers or Invest in AI? How to Decide with Data

In this article

The roadmap has slipped and a budget request lands on your desk: open new roles, or expand AI licenses and agents? Asking “will AI replace developers?” won’t settle it until you know where the work is getting stuck. This article offers four questions that point to the right path (hire, invest in AI, both or neither) using data leadership can track without reading code.

In short

  • AI is not replacing developers today. It changes where the work happens, and the gains of people writing code tend to stall in the review queue.
  • Hiring and investing in AI solve different problems: one adds capacity to the team, the other amplifies what the current team already produces.
  • The decision starts with where delivery gets stuck, not with comparing a license price to a salary.
  • If the team doesn’t actually use the AI the company already pays for, more licenses won’t change delivery.
  • A gap in knowledge, or in someone to own an area, calls for new developers. Repetitive work calls for tools.
  • Without a delivery baseline, any choice becomes a bet, and the result won’t show up at the next budget review.

Will AI replace developers? The question that comes first

No. At least not the way it usually comes up in budget meetings. For anyone picturing a team made only of AI, with no developers at all, the risk is high: someone has to decide what to build, review what the AI generates and answer when something breaks in production. Without that person, security and logic flaws go unnoticed and pile up, and the company comes to depend on a system nobody inside it understands or can fix. AI is already part of almost every tech team, but its gains depend on the team that receives it.

DORA’s State of AI-assisted Software Development report (Google, September 2025) surveyed nearly 5,000 professionals. Nine in ten already use AI at work, and more than 80% say it made them more productive. The study’s main conclusion, however, is a different one: AI works as an amplifier. In well-organized teams, it increases efficiency. In struggling teams, it makes weaknesses more visible.

Real-world usage data points the same way. Faros AI, an engineering analytics company, analyzed data from more than 10,000 developers across 1,255 teams (July 2025 report). On teams with higher AI adoption, each person completed 21% more tasks and the team merged almost twice as many pull requests (the bundles of code sent for review). But review time rose 91%. At the company level, the report found no significant relationship between AI adoption and more delivery.

So the useful question for whoever approves the budget isn’t whether AI replaces people. It’s which problem you are trying to solve. Hiring buys capacity and judgment: more people to take on areas and make decisions. Investing in AI buys leverage: the current team does more of what it already does. The four questions below show which of the two you are missing.

Question 1: where does delivery get stuck?

If work sits waiting for review, approval, another squad or a product decision, neither a new hire nor AI will fix it on their own. Both increase the volume of code that reaches that queue.

With AI, the effect shows up quickly. In the same Faros AI report, pull requests on high-adoption teams became about two and a half times larger on average, and each one took longer to review. The reviewer is usually the most experienced person on the team, who is exactly the hardest to multiply. With a new hire, the queue grows later: newcomers need the team’s time to ramp up, as we covered in Does hiring more developers to speed up delivery actually work?.

You don’t need to read code to find the bottleneck. Ask your CTO or Tech Lead to answer questions like these:

  • At which stage does work spend the most time waiting: development, review, testing or approval?
  • How many finished tasks are waiting for someone to review them?
  • How much of the work depends on another squad or on a definition that hasn’t arrived yet?
  • How much of the cycle goes to rework and bug fixing?

What the answer tells you: if the bottleneck is writing the code itself, hiring or investing in AI can help, and the next questions tell you which. If the bottleneck is in review, dependencies or decisions, the first investment is in the process. The article Is your tech team delivering late? 6 common causes helps you identify your case.

Question 2: does the team already use the AI you pay for?

An active license is not the same as AI in delivered work. Before buying more, find out how much of what you already bought has actually made it into the team’s day-to-day.

Users’ perception isn’t a measure either. In 2025, METR, a nonprofit research organization, followed experienced developers on real tasks. With AI, they took 19% longer to finish the work, yet believed they had become about 20% faster. In February 2026, METR itself marked that result as out of date. In the new round, some developers no longer agreed to work without AI, which made the numbers unreliable. The organization believes the gain is larger today, but admits it can’t yet measure by how much.

The lesson for business leaders is not that AI slows the team down. It’s that not even developers can tell, from feel alone, how much it helps. DORA found the same gap: only 24% of professionals say they trust AI output a lot or a great deal.

Questions worth asking your CTO:

  • How many people use AI on tasks that reach delivery, not just in experiments?
  • What kind of work does it go into: repetitive tasks, bug fixes or new features?
  • What has changed in the team’s delivery since AI arrived?

What the answer tells you: if adoption is low, the next investment is in training and in adjusting the workflow, not in more licenses. If adoption is high and delivery hasn’t changed, the bottleneck is somewhere else, and the answer lies in question 1. To calculate the return on what you have already invested, see AI coding ROI: how to calculate the return on copilots and agents.

Question 3: are you short on people or on specific knowledge?

AI handles repetitive, well-defined work well. It doesn’t take responsibility for a system, and it doesn’t know your business. So before deciding, separate two kinds of shortage.

Not enough hands for familiar tasks. Basic tests, small tweaks, code that follows a pattern the team already knows, documentation. If your most experienced people spend a good share of their time on this, AI tends to give hours back for the work only they can do.

No one to own an area. A new product, an integration with a legacy system, a security or regulatory requirement, an architecture decision that will last for years. What’s missing here is judgment and someone accountable for the outcome. AI speeds up people who already know the way, but it doesn’t choose the way.

There is also a long-term effect the cost spreadsheet doesn’t show. Whoever becomes senior a few years from now has to join the team at some point. Cutting every entry-level role because AI does part of a junior’s work solves this quarter and creates a team-building problem down the road.

What the answer tells you: repetitive work taking up experienced people points to investing in AI. An area without an owner, or knowledge the team doesn’t have, points to hiring.

Question 4: do you have a “before” to compare against?

Without a baseline, there is no way to know whether the hire or the AI worked. Two quarters from now, the budget conversation will rest on impressions, and, as we saw, the impression of people using AI is not a good measure.

The baseline that matters to business leaders isn’t technical. It’s four readings the tech team can put together:

  • Delivery pace: what was planned and what was delivered in each cycle.
  • Time to delivery: how long a request takes from start to reaching the customer.
  • Rework: how much of the cycle goes to fixing what had already been delivered.
  • Team cost for the period: payroll, licenses and AI tool usage.

With these numbers recorded before the decision, the question changes from “is AI helping?” to “what has changed since it arrived?”. The same goes for new hires: the comparison only makes sense after the ramp-up period, over several cycles, not in the first month.

What the answer tells you: if that “before” doesn’t exist, the first step is to record it, even if the decision can’t wait. A choice made without a baseline may still be right, but no one will be able to prove it later.

How to read the answers: hire, invest in AI, both or neither

Taken together, the four answers point to a path. The table sums up the most common scenarios.

What the answers show Path Why
Delivery gets stuck in review, approval or dependencies between squads Neither for now: fix the process More code, from new people or from AI, only grows the queue
The team barely uses the AI the company already pays for Invest in adoption (training and workflow) before buying more An idle license doesn’t change delivery
Experienced people spend time on repetitive work Invest in AI It gives hours back for the work only those people can do
No one owns a new area, or the team lacks a specific skill Hire AI speeds up people who know the way, but isn’t accountable for the outcome
Capacity is maxed out, the flow is healthy and AI is already in use Both: hire and bring AI into the workflow from day one The team already turns capacity into delivery
There is no baseline Measure first, even while you decide Without a “before”, no choice can be evaluated

None of these decisions is final. Tools, team and roadmap change, and the choice deserves a review every quarter, using the same baseline numbers.

Next step

All four questions depend on data most companies gather by hand. A spreadsheet put together by the tech team works at first, but it eats up hours and changes format every cycle. The dashboards of the AI tools themselves show how much each license is used, but not what changed in delivery. Devint is a platform that reads delivery and AI adoption together, at every closing, and is designed so leadership can follow it without reading code.

  • Delivery pace and AI and agent adoption are two of the six DevScore dimensions. Read together, they show whether AI usage shows up in the delivered work of each person and each squad.
  • Biweekly closings build the baseline and show the trend across cycles, before and after a new hire or a new tool.
  • Caps per dimension keep using more AI, or producing more code, from becoming a goal in itself. The number is there to open the right conversation with the team, not to decide for it.

The logic behind DevScore comes from more than 8 years of Espresso Labs managing thousands of developers. See how Devint shows what AI has already changed in your team’s delivery. If your next step is calculating the return on what you have already invested, start with the guide to AI coding ROI.

Frequently asked questions

Will AI replace developers in the coming years?

The available data doesn’t point that way. AI is already part of the work of almost every tech team, but its gains depend on process, on review and on the people accountable for decisions. What changes is the kind of work: less time writing repetitive code and more time reviewing, deciding and looking after the quality of what reaches the customer.

Is investing in AI cheaper than hiring a developer?

It depends on what goes into the calculation. Comparing only the license price with a salary is misleading. The cost of AI includes tool and agent usage, the team’s ramp-up time and extra review hours. The cost of a hire includes the period before the person is fully productive. And neither fixes a bottleneck that sits at another stage of delivery.

Can we shrink the team and keep delivery steady with AI?

Without a baseline, there’s no way to know. Before swapping people for tools, you need to measure over a few cycles whether the team’s delivery has changed since adoption. Even when it has, cutting every entry-level role creates another risk: no one is being trained to fill, a few years from now, the seats of today’s experienced people.

How long does it take to know whether the decision worked?

More than a month. New hires go through a ramp-up period, and the team also needs time to fold a new tool into its workflow. The best approach is to compare several delivery cycles against the baseline recorded before the decision, and to review the choice every quarter using the same numbers.

Do I need to understand code to hold the tech team accountable for AI results?

No. The questions that matter are business questions: where delivery gets stuck, how much of what was planned reached the customer, how much of the cycle goes to rework and what has changed since AI was adopted. Your CTO or Tech Lead can answer them, and leadership can follow the answers over time.

Sources

See the DevScore applied to your team.

Book a demo